Thursday, June 17, 2010

Wonder if the backbencher understands it now ...


The duffer's guide to the Resource Super Profits Tax

OK, IT"S complicated. But given the role the controversial Resource Super Profits Tax may play in our nation's economic prosperity, it's important to gain some grasp of it.

The Government says the old tax system has failed to keep pace with the spiralling profits generated by the big miners. The miners believe the new tax is not a tax on "super profits" but on very mild profits.

This is how the tax would work.

Under the current system, mining companies pay 5 per cent of annual income to the state where they operate as royalties.

A company earning $300 million in revenue would pay royalties of $15 million.

It then pays federal company tax. This is calculated by deducting operating expenses of say $100 million, another $95 million for depreciation of equipment and $5 million for interest on money borrowed to pay for day-to-day running of the business.

It also subtracts the $15 million royalty paid to the state. That gives a figure of $85 million which is taxed at 30 per cent - a total of roughly $26 million.

When added to royalties it leaves a total tax bill of $41 million, (41 per cent tax.) Under the proposed super profits tax, companies still pay the same amount for royalties.

The super tax kicks in after a company earns more than the government long-term bond rate (currently 5.7 per cent).

To calculate the super tax on $300 million a company deducts the $100 million operating expenses, $95 million for depreciation and a capital allowance from the Government to offset set-up expenses of about $5 million.

That leaves a total of $100 million, taxed at 40 per cent - or $40 million. The royalty already paid is then deducted, leaving a total of $25 million.

Company tax at the new lower rate of 28 per cent is then calculated using the existing equation, except the $25 million super tax is also deducted, leaving a total of $60 million to be taxed.

That would mean the company owed $17 million.

When the royalty, super tax and company tax are combined it comes to $57 million - or an effective tax rate of 57 per cent.

If a company fails to turn a profit, the government would reimburse 40 per cent of its initial investment.

Lowering the company tax rate to 28 per cent means miners who make a small profit will pay less tax.

The tax is retrospective and will be applied to projects already underway. The Government will reap upwards of $12 billion in the first two years, with a third going to a scheme to lift superannuation levies from 9 per cent to 12 per cent.


Go, check out the original article, there's a really neat graphical representation of the split up of the money. (I'ld post it here but this computer doesn't like putting pictures into blog posts?!?).

My concern over the tax is that living in WA, one of the two main states in Australia involved in mining, a lot of our prosperity and employment will be directly affected, I believe, if this goes ahead.

I believe that this will impact on companies' decisions to invest in Australia. There are many other places in the world where that investment capital could go, Canada being one, that I don't think the miners will just make noise, then settle down and get one with things.

Additionally, as the tax is retrospective and applies to current projects, I fear that there will be a down-scaling of these as well.

The other interesting thing is that this tax seems to be a tax on success. If you're a small miner who isn't doing too good you'll benefit. If you're a successful business / corporation you will be disadvantaged. This isn't therefore an incentive to be efficient. "Atlas Shrugged", anyone?


Old NFO said...

Yep Julie, you are dead right.
So who is going to be YOUR John Galt?

Crucis said...

Business can't continue with no profits. It's a stupid idea that tend to kill the goose that laid golden eggs.

No profit=no business=no taxes at all.

TOTWTYTR said...

One more time,

How can a freedom loving people like the Australians...

Seriously, high taxes such as this kill investment and enterprise.

Governments are like crack whores when it comes to money. Especially other people's money.